If you and a friend are cut from the same cloth it means you and your friend share many similarities. It could be that you and your friend seem to have been reared in a similar fashion or that circumstances molded both of you into having a similar mindset. Tailors use fabric from the same piece of cloth when making a garment to make sure the pieces match perfectly. Because there are slight differences between dye lots, it’s important to make garments from the same fabric so that the dye is even.
On August 10, 2008 the Sunday Mercury newspaper in Birmingham, England reviewed the CD “The Long Walk Home” by Neil Ivison and the Misers. Reviewed by Paul Cole, the opening line of the review was this:
Midland songwriter Neil Ivison is a singer cut from the same cloth as Paul Rodgers but his debut album isn’t a nostalgia trip, instead offering contemporary class and an energy that suggests barnstorming live gigs.
Almost 30 years earlier, the News and Courier newspaper in Charleston, South Carolina, published an article about Pastor Dr. R.L. Maddox and the Easter Sunday announcement he made to his congregation of 850 church followers. Perhaps it was coincidental that then-President Jimmy Carter‘s son, Jack, and daughter in law, Judy Carter, were part of the congregation at the time of his announcement as reported in the story, “Ga. Paster To Join Carter Staff.” The article began with this paragraph:
Dr. R.L. Maddox, who says he is “cut from the same cloth” as President Carter, said Sunday he will leave the First Baptist Church of Calhoun to become a White House speech writer.
The December 25, 1904 edition of the New York Times reviewed Donizetti’s Comedy at the Opera House which was hailed as a sparkling performance. Entitled, “L’Elisir d’Amore and Fidelio Given” the unnamed reviewer gave a succinct and extremely positive review of the performances. The reviewer stated in part:
It is of the same sort, cut from the same cloth and possessed of the same brilliant gayety. Its music is still fresh and buoyant — melody of the most facile Donizettian type, graceful and fluent and consorted most dextrously with the rippling comic action. It is all music that singers of the coloratura style delight to employ their powers in.
On February 10, 1888 the Atlanta Constitution ran a story entitled, “The Bogus Lard Ring” which dealt with members of the Georgia delegation in congress who were opposed to the Dawes and Butterworth bills. It would appear that the purpose of these bills was designed so additional taxes could be levied on the production of cotton seed oil thereby handicapping the growing southern industry. The article, harsh in its opinion of the proposed bills, stated in part:
It is of a piece with the entire republican system of taxation; it is cut from the same cloth.
Idiomation could continue jumping back in time, however, the earliest version of this saying goes back to Ancient Rome and Latin where the saying was “eiusdem farinae” sometimes written as “ejusdem farinae” which translates into “of the same flour.” Back in ancient times, it was as important to use flour that was milled at the same time so that one knew what to expect from baked goods. It’s no different than using the same bolt of fabric so one knows what to expect from a garment that is cut from the same cloth.